Yes, I have a different view. I reckon you could have completed the assessment in the time to took to provide 'considerable thought' to so many points of complaint.
First up, yes, it is an assessment, so yes, a time limit is generally applied where I come from. Three hours is plenty of time I would think, even if you are a busy person providing an immediate response to matters requiring your attention! Remember of course that you have already had UNLIMITED time to peruse the study guide, so the exam is just the final step.
Secondly, yes, as you have already mentioned, the purpose of this assessment IS for no other purpose than maintaining your own aircraft from what I understand. Many people are indicating that they shouldn't have to complete the assessment when they have been undertaking this maintenance for ever already. I can understand this frustration, however luckily, those that already have a vast knowledge of maintenance should find it an absolute snap to complete the assessment. Those that don't may just learn something - I'm sure I will!
I'm afraid also that from where I stand, it is possible that some students may be taught to fly with very minimal attention to maintenance, so I see it as a valuable safeguard with very minimal tradeoff in the form of some time.
If the website does the job, then how about you just do it? I'll bet if they spent extra $$ on a super flash website you'd be whinging about that too!
It is impossible to please everyone, but if makes far more sense to try to ensure some form of minimal standard of knowledge than to assume a level of knowledge to avoid offending anyone. In this day and age, people lacking knowledge who later become involved in an incident are usually very quick to try and shift blame and complaint that they were never provided with sufficient knowledge to save them from themselves.
As for the workbook vs assessment business - surely the word 'assessment' isn't too big and mean? I hope this isn't one of those times when people complain that the red pen on their school exams caused them issues, such that things should now be marked in green instead.....
Incidentally, the last (QAS) first aid course I completed had a (gasp) written assessment, (undertaken in less than 3 hrs). I think the underlying idea was safety and thus saving lives, much the same way that aircraft maintenance knowledge is aimed at further preventing your aircraft from suffering in flight issues which may therefore........save your life??
And yes, I'm sure others may have a different view to me also!