How much is it either an attachment to what we originally trained in, and perhaps even earlier dreams? I chose to start in Tomahawks and Warriors, and only flew the 152 and 172 later. I did feel that the high wings were a little easier to land, and having a little more sun off my head was a nice thing too. However....I chose low wing because I grew up on stories of WW2 aircraft, and one might suggest that a low wing looks a touch more like a fighter than a high wing.
Taking that a step further, I adore biplanes, and have a little time in a Pitts and a joyflight in a Tiger Moth. As a youngster, I read a lot of Biggles books, so to me, a biplane was the real dream (more so than the Spitfires etc of WW2). I would agree that the bipe can have the worst of both worlds, but to me it is worth it. That's why I have a set of plans for a bipe waiting for the time and space to come available.