So, kaz3g, you say you would permanently bar a pilot from membership?
If I were that pilot, I would have to fly illegally because the RAAus (by means of a disreputable act) would not accept my attempt to become legal.
You can see the court defense... " I wanted to go legal, your Worship, but they wouldn't let me. They said I was out for ever."
Two big threats to natural justice for members in the RAAus system are:
1) being accused by the RAAus kangaroo court of "bring RAAus into disrepute"
2) being accused of not being a "fit and proper person"...borrowed from CASA.
These provisions have, at times, been used as sledge hammers against members. Some previous Ops Managers were offenders in this area.
In fact, by their blunt force, unmeasured actions, said Ops Managers did, at the time, "bring RAAus into disrepute."
It is much wiser to keep offenders within the fold. Limited sanctions after due and full process is reasonable.
However, their should be no life long loss of membership...EVER.
Why? Because RAAus is, effectively, a monopoly. That has implications for the individual.