With the 2200, fuel consumption averages 3 US gallons per hour, never more than 4 when horsing around. It uses regular avgas, is air-cooled, and is direct drive. My Drifter weighs roughly 500 pounds empty and grosses at 1000 pounds. I weigh 170 pounds and have taken rear seat passengers as heavy as 250 pounds with no difficulty. Operationally, it starts right up, runs well, and probably puts out more thrust than this airplane needs. Full throttle at level flight would push the airplane past its 85 KIAS Vne. The extra horsepower is also helpful when teaching tailwheel - makes a go-around from a swerve or bounce an instant event.
Climb is wonderful. I regularly fly formation with a 1941 65 hp J-3 Piper Cub. Making a 10 second interval takeoff, I out accelerate and out climb him easily. The rejoin overtake and performance makes you feel as if you're flying a jet fighter - reminds me of my student days in the T-38 Talon.
The Jab does have specific valve adjustment and head torque tasks periodically. The engine also should not be run hot, however the uncowled Drifter poses no problem for that. The ignition system has no impulse couplings like a Lycoming engine, so a strong battery is a must for start.
Granted, we all have our opinions, but for power, climb, acceleration, and overall ease of operation and maintenance, I am very pleased with my Jab and, in fairness, I have very little experience with the 582. Regardless of the engine, the Drifter is my all-time favorite airplane!